Client Login

Tax Planning for a Large Bonus: Avoid a Surprise Bill

Written November 19, 2026Reviewed by: Mark Martukovich

Big Bonus or Windfall This Year? How to Plan Around the Withholding Gap

Good tax planning for a large bonus starts with one fact: employers usually withhold federal tax on bonuses and vested RSUs at a flat 22%, while many high earners pay 32% to 37% on that income. Liquidity events such as a property or stock sale often have no withholding at all. The fix is a projection that measures the gap before year-end, then closes it with withholding, estimated payments, or a cash reserve, and uses the high-income year to time deductions where they are worth the most.

A big bonus year should feel like a win. For a lot of households, it ends with an April tax bill that wipes out the good mood and sometimes a chunk of the savings. The reason is rarely a mistake on anyone's part. Payroll systems follow default rules that were never designed for your situation, and nobody connects the dots until the return is prepared.

Here is why the gap happens, what it costs, and how Harness Advisory Platform helps individuals plan around bonuses, equity vesting, and one-time sales before the year closes.

Why did my bonus create a tax bill?

Bonuses, commissions, and vested RSUs are supplemental wages. IRS Publication 15 allows employers to withhold federal income tax on supplemental wages at a flat 22% for amounts up to $1 million in a year, and requires 37% on amounts above $1 million. Most employers use the 22% method because it is simple.

The problem is that 22% is not your rate. If your household is in the 32%, 35%, or 37% bracket, every dollar of bonus is under-withheld by 10 to 15 cents before state tax is considered. On a $200,000 bonus, that can mean $20,000 to $30,000 owed at filing that never came out of a paycheck.

Medicare withholding can add a smaller surprise. Employers withhold the 0.9% additional Medicare tax only on wages above $200,000 per employer, regardless of filing status, while the actual threshold for joint filers is $250,000 of combined wages. Two high-earning spouses can each be under the employer threshold and still owe the tax together.

What makes liquidity events different?

A business sale, a large stock sale, a property sale, or a legal settlement often comes with no withholding at all. The full tax lands on your return. Long-term gains are taxed at 15% or 20%, and the 3.8% net investment income tax applies once modified AGI exceeds $250,000 for joint filers or $200,000 for single filers. State tax is on top of that, and many states tax gains as ordinary income.

A large one-time event can also trigger side effects that do not show up on the sale paperwork. The most notable for 2026 is the state and local tax deduction. The cap is $40,400, but it phases down by 30 cents for every dollar of modified AGI above $505,000, falling back to $10,000 at a little over $606,000. A household that was comfortably itemizing can lose most of that deduction in the year of a sale. The 35% cap on itemized charitable deductions for those in the top bracket, which began in 2026, is another.

How do I avoid an underpayment penalty after a windfall?

Two separate questions often get confused: whether you will owe a penalty, and how much you will owe in April.

For the penalty, IRS Publication 505 provides safe harbors. If your withholding and timely estimated payments cover at least 110% of last year's total tax (when last year's AGI was over $150,000), you generally avoid an underpayment penalty no matter how much you owe at filing. If your income arrived late in the year, the annualized income installment method on Form 2210 can reduce or eliminate a penalty by matching required payments to when the income was actually received.

Remember that withholding is treated as paid evenly through the year, while estimated payments count when made. If you are short on the safe harbor, increasing withholding on your remaining 2026 paychecks can cover earlier quarters. The fourth-quarter estimated payment, due January 15, 2027, only helps the last quarter.

Avoiding the penalty does not make the tax smaller. If you meet the safe harbor, you may legally be able to hold the remaining balance until April. That can be a smart cash decision, but only if the money is actually set aside.

What can I do before year-end to reduce the tax on a big income year?

  • Increase retirement deferrals on remaining paychecks if you have not reached the 2026 401(k) limit of $24,500.
  • Bunch charitable giving into this year, ideally by giving appreciated shares to a donor-advised fund. A deduction is worth more in a high-bracket year, even with the new 0.5% of AGI floor.
  • Harvest investment losses to offset gains from the sale, while avoiding wash sales across all household accounts.
  • Avoid stacking other income into the same year. A Roth conversion that makes sense in a normal year may not make sense in this one.
  • If a sale has not closed, ask whether an installment structure or a January closing would spread the gain more efficiently.
  • Review next year now. Many employers' nonqualified deferred compensation plans require you to elect deferral of next year's bonus before December 31 of this year.

What does planning around a big income year look like?

The following is a fictional example created to illustrate how Harness Advisory Platform would approach this situation. It is not a real client.

Fatima is a vice president of sales at a software company in Ohio. Her base salary is $240,000, and her spouse earns $130,000. In 2026, Fatima received a $150,000 bonus in March and $120,000 of RSUs vested over the year, both withheld at 22%. In October, the couple sold a rental property they had owned for nine years, realizing a gain of about $200,000. No tax was withheld on the sale.

In mid-November, our advisory team builds a full projection. Their ordinary income now sits in the 35% bracket, the gain is taxed at 20% and carries the 3.8% net investment income tax, and their modified AGI is far enough above the phase-down range that their SALT deduction falls to $10,000. The good news is that their withholding will clear 110% of last year's tax, so no underpayment penalty applies. The less good news is a projected balance due of roughly $85,000 in April.

The plan has four parts. First, about $90,000 of the sale proceeds goes into a separate short-term Treasury account earmarked for April, rather than sitting in the household checking account. Second, a stock fund in their brokerage account with an unrealized loss is sold and replaced, offsetting part of the gain. Third, they give appreciated company shares to a donor-advised fund, covering three years of planned giving. Fourth, Fatima elects to defer part of her 2027 bonus through her employer's deferred compensation plan before the December 31 deadline, and both spouses adjust their 2027 withholding to account for the 22% gap on future bonuses and vesting.

April will still bring a bill. It will be smaller, it will be expected, and the cash will be waiting.

What steps should you take if you had a big income year?

  1. List every bonus, RSU vest, and sale, along with what was actually withheld on each.
  2. Build a projection using your real marginal rate, not the withholding rate.
  3. Check whether you meet the safe harbor. If not, increase withholding on remaining paychecks.
  4. Set aside the projected balance due in a separate account.
  5. Use the high-income year for deductions that benefit most from it, such as charitable bunching and retirement deferrals.
  6. Make next year's elections now, including deferred compensation elections and updated withholding.
Schedule time with a Harness Advisory Platform advisor today.

When should you call an advisor about a windfall?

Ideally before the money arrives. The best options for a bonus, a vesting schedule, or a sale usually exist months ahead of the event. Any CPA firm can record history. As your tax advisory partner, we help you build a future in which big income years are planned, funded, and free of surprises. If you are expecting a bonus, equity vesting, or a sale in the next year, now is the time to start.

Learn more about individual tax advisory and planning at: https://busadvisory.com/individual-tax-advisory-planning/

Book your conversation at: https://busadvisory.com/schedule-your-advisory-fit-meeting/

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did my bonus create a tax bill?

Your bonus likely created a tax bill because your employer withheld federal tax at a flat 22%, while your actual marginal rate is higher. For households in the 32%, 35%, or 37% brackets, that leaves 10 to 15 cents of every bonus dollar unpaid until filing. RSU vesting works the same way. A projection before year-end shows the gap while there is still time to address it.

How much tax should I withhold on a bonus?

You should aim to cover your actual marginal rate on the bonus, not just the default 22% supplemental rate. Many employers will not change the bonus withholding rate itself, so the usual fix is increasing withholding on regular paychecks through Form W-4. The right amount depends on your total household income and state tax. Run a projection before making the change.

Will I pay a penalty if I owe a lot after a windfall?

Not necessarily, because the safe harbor rules can protect you even when you owe a large balance. If withholding and timely estimated payments cover at least 110% of last year's tax (for prior-year AGI over $150,000), you generally avoid a penalty. If the income came late in the year, the annualized income method may also help. You still owe the full tax by the filing deadline.

Do I need to make estimated payments after selling a property or business?

Often yes, because sales usually have no withholding, and the tax on a large gain can push you below the safe harbor. Whether you must pay depends on your total withholding and payments compared with the safe harbor thresholds. The fourth-quarter payment is due January 15, 2027. A projection tells you whether to pay now or set the money aside for April.

What can I do before year-end to lower taxes in a high-income year?

You can maximize retirement deferrals, bunch charitable gifts, harvest investment losses, and avoid adding other income such as Roth conversions. Deductions are worth more in a high-bracket year. Review deferred compensation elections for next year, since many are due by December 31. Each move should be checked against a full-year projection.

Copyright © BAAP 2026 All Rights Reserved
crosschevron-down